Rich Miller

Rich Miller

Census data may bolster Dem-drawn map

By Rich Miller

In the wake of last week’s Census numbers release, the news media has widely reported a seeming reduction in the number of white people, both nationally and here in Illinois.

“Census shows U.S. is diversifying, white population shrinking,” the Associated Press reported. “Overall, in the five collar counties, the white population declined by 183,869 over the past decade,” the Chicago Tribune reported.

RichMiller 1

Rich Miller

But is that true?

The U.S. Census Bureau itself claims that racial and Hispanic origin population changes are “largely due to improvements in the design of the two separate questions for race data collection and processing as well as some demographic changes over the past 10 years.” The Census Bureau has been working since 2015 to find a different way to ask questions that yielded more informative and realistic results. The Bureau now claims the tweaks it ended up making to its questions yielded “a more accurate portrait of how people report their Hispanic origin and race.”

In other words, while significant population increases, decreases, movements and racial mixtures did undoubtedly occur, the new Census questions mean people are supposedly now more able to self-define who they really are, and that has resulted in a major change in the results.

“(T)he number of people identifying as white alone dropped 14% during the 10-year period,” the State Journal-Register reported on the Illinois results. “Meanwhile, the number of people who said they are white and at least one other race rose by 334%, or 820,879 people.” If the Census Bureau is right about the impact of its changes, then all those 800,000-plus people didn’t just materialize in the past decade. Many or even most were already here.

The same goes for black people. “The number of people identifying as black alone, about 1.8 million people, dropped 3.1%,” in Illinois, the SJ-R reported. “However, those who said they were black and at least one other race increased by 76,243, or almost 89%.”

The 15 percent increase here of folks with “Hispanic origin” may have as much to do with the Bureau’s new and “more accurate portrait” than an actual change.

Anyway, it’s food for thought, especially since legislative and congressional districts are drawn with those results in mind.

The annual American Community Survey is a very large poll, but it isn’t a meticulous head count like the Census; so it isn’t quite as accurate. But because Census data wasn’t available, the House and Senate Democrats this past spring used averaged ACS data to draw state legislative maps.

How did that work out?

Well, in the City of Chicago alone, the ACS numbers used by Illinois Democrats appeared to undercount Hispanic origin voters by 43,228, according to my consultant, Frank Calabrese, who compared the ACS data with the newly released Census count.

For all of Cook County, the ACS data the Democrats used for Hispanic origin ended up being 63,495 fewer than the official Census count. In Lake County, where Latino activists hoped to create a new majority-minority district, the ACS undercount was 15,690.

So, what does this mean? We don’t yet know where those undercounted folks precisely are. Frank needed a few more days to plug the new numbers into the newly drawn legislative districts.

If those undercounted Hispanic origin residents mostly live in newly drawn districts that lean or are majority Latino, then that will help the Democrats in the legal challenge brought against the new maps by Latino organizations by boosting the final Hispanic origin percentages in those districts. In other words, the newly drawn districts may very well end up looking “better” than they did with the ACS numbers, as far as the legal case goes.

But if those undercounted folks do not live in the new Latino-based districts, then the Democrats could be forced back to the drawing board before a judge rules against them.

Since we can’t yet get to the district numbers, I had Calabrese compare the county-level ACS results with county-level Census results. Legislative districts are supposed to be “substantially equal,” and courts in the past have generally defined that term as under 10 percent difference in population between districts.

The result of Calabrese’s inquiry was that no Illinois county’s ACS population used to draw the maps deviated more than 10 percent from the final Census numbers. Only two were even close. The average statewide deviation between ACS and the Census was 1.11 percent. The Democrats’ case could be helped again.

Rich Miller also publishes Capitol Fax, a daily political newsletter, and CapitolFax.com.

Local News

Angel Williams, of South Carolina, enjoyed being able to phone home to his mom and his fiancé. (Photos by Steve Metsch)

Brookfield VFW Post gives 45 Navy recruits a happy Thanksgiving Day

By Steve Metsch It had been about three months since Brittney Rodriguez sat down to enjoy a home-cooked meal. It’s not that the food is terrible at the Great Lakes Recruit Training Center in North Chicago, Rodriguez said. It’s just not as good as Mom’s cooking. “They have their days, but it’s not a home-cooked…

Team captain Zach Hayes holds the trophy as Coach Tim Racki and the Roadrunners celebrate the school’s fourth state football championship in nine seasons, and first since 2018. (Photos by Steve Metsch)

Nazareth rally celebrates fourth state football championship

By Steve Metsch Two huge cheers rocked the Rooney Student Center at Nazareth Academy in La Grange Park late Monday morning. The first was when Zach Hayes – joined by the coaches and teammates – walked in carrying the IHSA Class 5A state football championship trophy high over his head. The second was when school…

Members of Orland Park's Dance Company dance during Sunday's holiday parade. (Photos by Jeff Vorva)

Orland Park gets in the holiday spirit with parade and tree lighting

By Jeff Vorva The Village of Orland Park’s lighting of the Christmas tree ceremony has been going on for decades, but its holiday parade just completed its sophomore run. The second holiday parade kicked off the festivities on Sunday followed by Mayor Keith Pekau and a group of children pulling the switch to not only…

bridgeview police logo - Copy

Pedestrian, 70, hit by car, dies crossing Harlem Avenue in Bridgeview

By Steve Metsch A 70-year-old Bridgeview man died after he was hit by a car at 6:45 p.m. Monday in the 8100 block of South Harlem Avenue, Police Chief Ricardo Mancha said. The man identified as Brian Callaghan was walking from the east side of Harlem to the west, Mancha said. Callaghan lived at Moraine…

Screen Shot 2022-11-30 at 1.57.20 PM

A Thanksgiving surprise

The kindergarteners at St. Daniel the Prophet School had a surprise visitor earlier this month–known to them as Army National Guard Sergeant Bryan Dudycha. But one student in the class knows him as Daddy; and when she saw him, Madison leapt into his arms, gleeful over his return from deployment, just in time for Thanksgiving.…

SRP-IMAGE-Logo

Clear-Ridge Reporter and NewsHound November 30, 2022

Mary Stanek

Hang out your socks for St. Nick

By Mary Stanek Your correspondent in Archer Heights and West Elsdon 3808 W. 57th Place • (773) 284-7394 Hang out those socks on the night of Monday, Dec. 5. St. Nicholas day is here on Tuesday, Dec. 6. St. Nick was known for selling all of his possessions and giving to the poor. He may…

Kathy Headley

Thanksgiving was fun, and delicious

By Kathy Headley Your correspondent in Chicago Lawn and Marquette Manor 6610 S. Francisco • (773) 776-7778 Hope your Thanksgiving was as fun and happy as ours. As always, the aroma and taste of home cooking and holiday desserts were a big part of the day. I feel comfortable telling you where we picked up…

CRRNH_SweetSaluteRhineVFW_112322

A sweet salute to veterans

Rhine VFW Post 2729 members William Haas and Jerry Dipasquale survey some of the bags of candy, pastries and other treats given to the post earlier this month by the students of Sahs School in Central Stickney. The Sahs boys and girls also wrote personal letters and made patriotic posters expressing their thanks and appreciation…

Summit Trustee Aleco Julius (from left), Summit Trustee Sam Dardovski, Summit Fire Captain Anthony Anderson, Summit Police Chief Mel Ortiz, Summit Mayor Sergio Rodriguez stand in front of the village Christmas tree. (Photo by Carol McGowan)

Summit lights Christmas tree, holds last Neighborhood Watch for the year

By Carol McGowan Summit officials and residents were on hand November 17 for the lighting of the village Christmas tree in front of the police station on Archer Road. In what’s become an annual event the last couple of years, the tree is lit before the last Neighborhood Watch meeting for the year. There is…

Neighbors

DVN JCs Restoration House Ad
Angel Williams, of South Carolina, enjoyed being able to phone home to his mom and his fiancé. (Photos by Steve Metsch)

Brookfield VFW Post gives 45 Navy recruits a happy Thanksgiving Day

By Steve Metsch It had been about three months since Brittney Rodriguez sat down to enjoy a home-cooked meal. It’s not that the food is terrible at the Great Lakes Recruit Training Center in North Chicago, Rodriguez said. It’s just not as good as Mom’s cooking. “They have their days, but it’s not a home-cooked…

Team captain Zach Hayes holds the trophy as Coach Tim Racki and the Roadrunners celebrate the school’s fourth state football championship in nine seasons, and first since 2018. (Photos by Steve Metsch)

Nazareth rally celebrates fourth state football championship

By Steve Metsch Two huge cheers rocked the Rooney Student Center at Nazareth Academy in La Grange Park late Monday morning. The first was when Zach Hayes – joined by the coaches and teammates – walked in carrying the IHSA Class 5A state football championship trophy high over his head. The second was when school…

Members of Orland Park's Dance Company dance during Sunday's holiday parade. (Photos by Jeff Vorva)

Orland Park gets in the holiday spirit with parade and tree lighting

By Jeff Vorva The Village of Orland Park’s lighting of the Christmas tree ceremony has been going on for decades, but its holiday parade just completed its sophomore run. The second holiday parade kicked off the festivities on Sunday followed by Mayor Keith Pekau and a group of children pulling the switch to not only…

bridgeview police logo - Copy

Pedestrian, 70, hit by car, dies crossing Harlem Avenue in Bridgeview

By Steve Metsch A 70-year-old Bridgeview man died after he was hit by a car at 6:45 p.m. Monday in the 8100 block of South Harlem Avenue, Police Chief Ricardo Mancha said. The man identified as Brian Callaghan was walking from the east side of Harlem to the west, Mancha said. Callaghan lived at Moraine…

Screen Shot 2022-11-30 at 1.57.20 PM

A Thanksgiving surprise

The kindergarteners at St. Daniel the Prophet School had a surprise visitor earlier this month–known to them as Army National Guard Sergeant Bryan Dudycha. But one student in the class knows him as Daddy; and when she saw him, Madison leapt into his arms, gleeful over his return from deployment, just in time for Thanksgiving.…

SRP-IMAGE-Logo

Clear-Ridge Reporter and NewsHound November 30, 2022

Mary Stanek

Hang out your socks for St. Nick

By Mary Stanek Your correspondent in Archer Heights and West Elsdon 3808 W. 57th Place • (773) 284-7394 Hang out those socks on the night of Monday, Dec. 5. St. Nicholas day is here on Tuesday, Dec. 6. St. Nick was known for selling all of his possessions and giving to the poor. He may…

Kathy Headley

Thanksgiving was fun, and delicious

By Kathy Headley Your correspondent in Chicago Lawn and Marquette Manor 6610 S. Francisco • (773) 776-7778 Hope your Thanksgiving was as fun and happy as ours. As always, the aroma and taste of home cooking and holiday desserts were a big part of the day. I feel comfortable telling you where we picked up…

CRRNH_SweetSaluteRhineVFW_112322

A sweet salute to veterans

Rhine VFW Post 2729 members William Haas and Jerry Dipasquale survey some of the bags of candy, pastries and other treats given to the post earlier this month by the students of Sahs School in Central Stickney. The Sahs boys and girls also wrote personal letters and made patriotic posters expressing their thanks and appreciation…

Summit Trustee Aleco Julius (from left), Summit Trustee Sam Dardovski, Summit Fire Captain Anthony Anderson, Summit Police Chief Mel Ortiz, Summit Mayor Sergio Rodriguez stand in front of the village Christmas tree. (Photo by Carol McGowan)

Summit lights Christmas tree, holds last Neighborhood Watch for the year

By Carol McGowan Summit officials and residents were on hand November 17 for the lighting of the village Christmas tree in front of the police station on Archer Road. In what’s become an annual event the last couple of years, the tree is lit before the last Neighborhood Watch meeting for the year. There is…

House Ad Subscription2
CRR NH Fireside Realty House Ad