Cook County Treasurer Maria Pappas

Cook County Treasurer Maria Pappas

Pappas: tax investors make millions from black, Latino communities

Spread the love

Study shows homeowners, gov’t losing out on funding

From staff reports

A new study from the Cook County Treasurer’s Office concludes that hedge funds, private equity firms and others are exploiting a loophole in Illinois’ property tax law to make millions of dollars in profits, mostly at the expense of black and Latino communities.

These investors, known as tax buyers, have helped shape the arcane section of the property tax law they now use to their advantage, the report says. They have drained nearly $280 million from Cook County taxing districts over the last seven years. Of that, 87% came from black and Latino communities.

“Investors from all over the country are drawn to our tax sale like it was the California Gold Rush,” Cook County Treasurer Maria Pappas said. “They’re getting rich from struggling communities. The money they make from the law they helped rewrite should be going to schools, parks, police departments and other government agencies.”

MariaPappas

Cook County Treasurer Maria Pappas

Tax buyers pay property owners’ delinquent taxes, aiming to make money when the taxpayer repays that debt, at steep interest rates. The tax buyer gets a lien on the properties on which he or she paid the taxes. That lien allows the tax buyer to take properties if taxpayers don’t pay their debt within a specified time period.

But these investors usually do not want to take possession of a property. They have an out: Illinois’ broad and forgiving sale-in-error statute that allows the tax buyers to avoid taking the property and instead get back their investment, often with interest.

Many states have policies that allow tax buyers to get repaid when the government has sold a property it shouldn’t have, including when the property is government-owned or when the taxpayer made good on their debt before the sale.

In Illinois, however, tax buyers can get their money back for “errors” by any county official even when the “errors” would not have prevented a sale or do not cause financial harm to the tax buyer. Tax buyers helped rewrite the property tax law in 1951, allowing them to get their money back for errors they had committed. In 1983, state lawmakers expanded the scope of the law to include errors by county officials, creating a loophole tax buyers have exploited ever since.

The Pappas study cited “frivolous” reasons for which tax buyers got their money back, with interest:

  • A house was listed as made of stucco when it was made of brick.
  • A two-story commercial building was listed as having 0 square feet of space.
  • A home was listed as not having air conditioning when it did.

When a tax sale is undone due to a sale in error, most of the money paid to the tax buyer comes from the revenue of local governments, especially harming cash-strapped black and Latino communities where the majority of tax sales occur, Pappas said.

The Treasurer’s research team surveyed government financial offices in large out-of-state municipalities that sell taxes. None reported having anything like Illinois’ sale-in-error statute. In other states, “buyer beware” was the tax sale motto. Tax buyers must do their own due diligence and assume the risk. No other government granted refunds for government website errors.

“We don’t have that problem, thank goodness,” said Michelle Jones, the Newark, N.J. tax collector, about the frivolous reasons that sales in error are routinely used by tax buyers in Illinois. “That’s ridiculous. You need to amend that. I think they’re taking advantage of you guys.”

Pappas’ study makes many recommendations for state legislative changes, including:

  • Changing Illinois law to require tax buyers to prove an error was “material” to the tax sale and they were financially harmed. This would prevent them from profiting from frivolous mistakes.
  • Disallowing sales in error for mistakes on the Assessor’s website, given that the Assessor tracks nearly 1.8 million properties, making it impossible to be totally current on the status of each property.

Several county agencies also made errors, including not serving the required taxpayer warnings on time and assigning incorrect addresses to properties. The Treasurer also made recommendations aimed at reducing those errors.

In what she called an extraordinary display of local government transparency and accountability, Pappas ordered her research unit to explore faults in the sale-in-error law, even if part of the problem could be traced back to her office. The research team found that the Treasurer’s Office had erroneously sold the taxes on government-owned properties, scores of which were highways, and on other properties that were tied up in a bankruptcy proceeding at the time of the sale.

Local News

Sorry, we couldn't find any posts. Please try a different search.

Neighbors

Capitol Briefs: Advocates push for guaranteed income, child care assistance

Capitol Briefs: Advocates push for guaranteed income, child care assistance

By HANNAH MEISEL & DILPREET RAJU Capitol News Illinois news@capitolnewsillinois.com The Illinois Supreme Court on Wednesday agreed to hear the case of actor Jussie Smollett, who was convicted for staging a hate crime against him in 2019 in a case that drew criticism for Cook County’s top prosecutor. Smollett made what turned out to be…

Illinois teacher shortage persists, survey finds

Illinois teacher shortage persists, survey finds

By PETER HANCOCK  Capitol News Illinois  phancock@capitolnewsillinois.com  SPRINGFIELD – Illinois continues to suffer from a shortage of teachers and other education professionals, although recent efforts by the state to ease the strain have made an impact.  That’s according to the latest annual survey of school officials from the Illinois Association of Regional Superintendents of Schools,…

Bills in state Senate would further regulate battery storage and disposal

Bills in state Senate would further regulate battery storage and disposal

COLE LONGCOR Capitol News Illinois clongcor@capitolnewsillinois.com SPRINGFIELD — Two bills that would regulate battery disposal and storage are awaiting action from the full Illinois Senate after unanimous committee approval.   Senate Bill 3481, sponsored by Sen. Sara Feigenholtz, D-Chicago, would require facilities that store electric vehicle batteries to register with the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency…

Prisoner Review Board chair, member resign in wake of boy’s fatal stabbing by released inmate

Prisoner Review Board chair, member resign in wake of boy’s fatal stabbing by released inmate

By HANNAH MEISEL Capitol News Illinois hmeisel@capitolnewsillinois.com The longtime chair and a relatively new member of the Illinois Prisoner Review Board have resigned, Gov. JB Pritzker’s office announced Monday. The governor’s office announced the pair’s resignations within hours of each other nearly two weeks after Crosetti Brand was released from Stateville Correctional Center. Brand is…

Highest-ranking woman in state police history reflects on experience as force looks to diversify

Highest-ranking woman in state police history reflects on experience as force looks to diversify

By ALEX ABBEDUTO   Capitol News Illinois  abbeduto@capitolnewsillinois.com  The night before Rebecca Hooks started at the Illinois State Police Academy in 2002, she spoke on the phone with her father and her brother – both of whom worked in law enforcement.  Her father encouraged her, telling her she was strong and could get through the…

After being rebuffed by regulators, utilities file slimmed-down spending plans

After being rebuffed by regulators, utilities file slimmed-down spending plans

 By ANDREW ADAMS Capitol News Illinois aadams@capitolnewsillinois.com CHICAGO — State regulators are once again considering massive electric utility spending plans that would affect the state’s climate goals – and 5.4 million electric customers’ monthly bills – after rejecting previous versions late last year. The Illinois Commerce Commission forced the state’s two major electric utilities, Commonwealth…

After being rebuffed by regulators, utilities file slimmed-down spending plans

After being rebuffed by regulators, utilities file slimmed-down spending plans

 By ANDREW ADAMS Capitol News Illinois aadams@capitolnewsillinois.com CHICAGO — State regulators are once again considering massive electric utility spending plans that would affect the state’s climate goals – and 5.4 million electric customers’ monthly bills – after rejecting previous versions late last year. The Illinois Commerce Commission forced the state’s two major electric utilities, Commonwealth…

After being rebuffed by regulators, utilities file slimmed-down spending plans

After being rebuffed by regulators, utilities file slimmed-down spending plans

 By ANDREW ADAMS Capitol News Illinois aadams@capitolnewsillinois.com CHICAGO — State regulators are once again considering massive electric utility spending plans that would affect the state’s climate goals – and 5.4 million electric customers’ monthly bills – after rejecting previous versions late last year. The Illinois Commerce Commission forced the state’s two major electric utilities, Commonwealth…

After being rebuffed by regulators, utilities file slimmed-down spending plans

After being rebuffed by regulators, utilities file slimmed-down spending plans

 By ANDREW ADAMS Capitol News Illinois aadams@capitolnewsillinois.com CHICAGO — State regulators are once again considering massive electric utility spending plans that would affect the state’s climate goals – and 5.4 million electric customers’ monthly bills – after rejecting previous versions late last year. The Illinois Commerce Commission forced the state’s two major electric utilities, Commonwealth…

Capitol Briefs: Insurance reforms advance as Pritzker announces California trip

Capitol Briefs: Insurance reforms advance as Pritzker announces California trip

By PETER HANCOCK, JENNIFER FULLER & ALEX ABBEDUTO Capitol News Illinois news@capitolnewsillinois.com SPRINGFIELD – Gov. JB Pritzker’s proposal for sweeping reforms in the state’s health insurance industry passed out of a committee Thursday and will soon make its way to the full House for consideration. Pritzker first outlined the proposal in his State of the…